$9.99 Each Set. The L.L.Bean comforter includes thoughtful touches like duvet loops, which help keep the comforter positioned inside a duvet cover with corner ties. We looked at a range of budget options from retailers like Amazon, JCPenney, and other big-box stores. And this comforter is easy to wash at home (which our 8-year-old kid tester recommends doing right away, to soften up the percale shell). Stock issues and delays in shipping are not usually a deal breaker, since these issues are especially more common during a pandemic, but customer service not responding is something we take seriously. Most down-alternative comforters don’t breathe well, but when we slept with the Utopia, we rarely woke up because we were too hot or too cold. Its comforters not only meet the Responsible Down Standard requirements, but each comforter also comes with a tracking number that buyers can enter at TrackMyDown to see the source of each comforter’s fill. In 2019 and 2020 we tested a total of 21 comforters in down, down alternative, and wool, including retests of four existing picks from Riley, L.L.Bean, Feathered Friends, and Utopia. The L.L.Bean Classic Colors Down Comforter has 600 fill power and great reviews, but it’s so thin that it feels more like a summer-weight comforter. “They’re surprisingly soft, and the filling is evenly distributed.” She notes that the corner loops are small, which makes threading through duvet cover ties a challenge. The Casaluna comforter is made with 600-fill-power duck down, and it’s heavier than the Riley comforter. Full / Queen: 88in. This means the Riley’s down clusters have more room to puff up inside the baffle boxes, trapping more heat, providing better insulation, and making the Riley feel perfectly warm while still being light enough to use year-round (depending on your preference and climate). We heard some negative reports about Riley’s ability to fulfill orders and give adequate customer support. It’s difficult to sort out exactly where down is coming from, let alone whether it was collected by plucking a live duck or a live goose. Pacific Coast searched the world to bring you exceptional and rare Pyrenees Down from the renowned Pyrenees Mountain region of France. We’ve also tested the Essential Down Blanket, a lighter version of this comforter (same fill power, just less of it) for our bed blankets guide; it’s a solid choice for warmer climates or to pair with another blanket or your child’s favorite printed comforter (it also comes in a Core-Loft version). Though not as luxurious or as light as the down options we tested, the fiberfill Utopia Bedding Queen Comforter Duvet Insert remains the best under-$50 option we’ve tried. L.L.Bean offers a one-year satisfaction guarantee (and addresses problems on a case-by-case basis thereafter). Eventually, down clusters may even fully disintegrate. The Full / Queen Size is on sale for $44.99 (after instant savings). Although there’s no industry-standard warmth rating in the US, most companies break it down simply: light, medium (often called all-season), and heavy. But this also means the down won’t shift inside the comforter, and (according to some of our experts) it will be easier to wash at home. Filled with down alternative or polyester, it provides protection minus the bulk–great for warm sleepers. Target’s product description page says duck, and we’re sure that’s true given the price, but it was an odd omission since most companies clearly specify the animal on the label. The cotton sateen shell retained heat without making us sweat, and in our tests it kept all the down inside. We eliminated it immediately. (Contact with skin oils can make both cotton and down degrade more quickly over time than they otherwise would.) $79.00 - $119.00. We found the Utopia to be better at regulating heat than the higher-priced down-alternative comforters we tried from Brooklinen and Snowe. Ultimately, though, we found the 25-ounce all-season comforter plenty warm and lofty, unlike the limp summer-weight comforters we’ve tried from other brands. The queen-size extra-warmth version has 34 ounces of down in 750 fill power, which is a more-common comforter fill weight (and comparable to our picks from Feathered Friends and L.L.Bean). Oeko-Tex–certified Terribly uneven fill: nearly no down … Here’s a breakdown of what the terms mean and, even more important, how they might factor into your decision-making process. All sizes cost less than $50, so we think that this comforter would be a great choice for a child’s bed or in a guest room. Rest easy with our machine-washable down alternative comforters, available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King sizes. We focused on employing the comforters as most people would in their own homes, spending a night or two under each and using five sleep testers—including an 8-year-old child—over the course of two years. Fill power and fill type: siliconized fiberfillConstruction: sewn-throughCertifications: n/aSizes available: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king/California king. At just over 5 pounds, it’s the lightest we’ve tested, and it feels durable—it should easily last for decades if you care for it properly. It's available in six different sizes to fit any bed and three different weights depending on what level of warmth you need. The microfiber fill is shaved to feel fluffy like real down and the outer fabric is made of 100% cotton. The world of down comforters has its own language, and it can be confusing. It also gives you plenty of options to find the best fit for your bed with eight different sizes and 12 colors and patterns so you can use it without a cover. We didn’t notice that extra weight once we were sleeping under it, though, and it kept us perfectly warm when we opened the windows on a 50ish-degree Fahrenheit night. Comforters tend to sell out in the fall, but this year we’ve seen more stock problems than ever on all of our picks. 00 $85.99 $85.99. Jackie Reeve is a senior staff writer covering bedding, organization, and home goods at Wirecutter since 2015. For Alex’s 2019 update, two testers slept in a bedroom with average temperatures between 65 and 70 degrees Fahrenheit—similar to a room with the heat turned on. If you’re allergic to down or not keen on using animal products, opt for a down-alternative comforter. This comforter is nearly as puffy as the Riley, although the Riley’s down clusters are larger. Both goose down and duck down can make excellent comforters, so there’s no reason to turn your nose up at a down puff’s provenance. Despite its roughness, this shell is still breathable, and it’s woven densely enough to prevent feathers from escaping. “If you wash it every year, it’s just going to send you back to get [a new comforter] sooner.” Use a duvet cover to maximize the time needed between washings. The diminished quality, along with issues we’ve had with Snowe’s customer service in the past, make it impossible for us to recommend this comforter. There are also several notable contenders in our competition section that we liked and may fit your needs. Noble Excellence Lightweight Warmth Down Alternative Comforter Duvet Insert. The L.L.Bean comforter is both Responsible Down Standard– and Oeko-Tex–certified (the Riley carries only RDS certification). The Queen size is on sale for $54.99 (after instant savings). We also tried both the Alberta and White Bay’s light comforter options, and both felt too thin. We still stand by the quality of Riley’s comforter but are looking into how they address their customer service complaints. Although many of them came with budget-friendly prices, the comforters were substantially lacking in quality. This brand says their comforter "feels like a hug from a cloud" and we totally get why: Both the fill and the outer fabric are super soft and cozy without feeling heavy. From left: Target Fieldcrest Warmest Down Comforter (now discontinued), Feathered Friends Bavarian Medium 700 Down Comforter, and Riley White Goose Down Comforter. It has less fill than many comforters we’ve tested, but its baffle-box construction keeps the down clusters lofty, and the dense sateen cover (the smoothest of any we’ve tried) keeps the clusters—and heat—from escaping. If you have a baffle-box comforter, Sukelac said you’ll need to take it out of the dryer a few times to shake it and try to redistribute the down as it dries. This gorgeous (and pricey) down comforter is much loftier than any other we’ve ever tried—imagine being enveloped in a luxurious cloud. new! But for the price, we think you’d be better off going with our upgrade pick from Feathered Friends, which feels much loftier. To make a comforter warmer in the fall and winter, add a flannel cover, and for spring and summer, opt for a lightweight linen or percale cover. Riley’s Down Alternative comforter felt as good as many down comforters we’ve tried. The L.L.Bean Baffle-Box Stitch Down Comforter is among our favorites—it kept us warm and cozy without causing us to sweat. We tested both the Buffy Cloud and Breeze comforters—and even slept for a night with the Cloud—but they were both extremely heavy on our bodies and didn’t breathe at all. The L.L.Bean comforter is also similarly constructed, with baffle boxes to create loft and allow air to circulate freely. We also tested the Light and Ultra versions of this comforter, in case one of those weights fits your warmth needs better. Fill power and feather type: 700 fill power, white goose downConstruction: baffle boxCertifications: Responsible Down StandardSizes available: twin, full/queen, king. Riley has acknowledged the issue and they’ve told us they have instituted fixes but we’re keeping an eye on how things develop. L.L.Bean uses reinforced perma baffles, which the company says are more durable and prevent the down from shifting. ( 9) color swatch. Enjoy free shipping and easy returns every day at Kohl's. Users sing its praises for being lightweight and fluffy. But it kept us warm, and the heavier weight didn’t bother our child or adult tester. Because we had many lighter-weight down-alternative options, we cut this one. © 2021 Wirecutter, Inc., A New York Times Company, L.L.Bean Baffle-Box Stitch Down Comforter, L.L.Bean Baffle-Box Stitch Down Comforter, Warm, A favorite comforter (when it’s available), Target Casaluna Mid Weight Down Comforter, Feathered Friends Bavarian Medium 700 Down Comforter, Utopia Bedding Queen Comforter Duvet Insert, How to choose the best comforter weight for you, Our pick: Riley White Goose Down Comforter, Runner-up: L.L.Bean Baffle-Box Stitch Down Comforter, Warm, Budget pick: Target Casaluna Mid Weight Down Comforter, Upgrade pick: Feathered Friends Bavarian Medium 700 Down Comforter, Also great: Utopia Bedding Queen Comforter Duvet Insert, Also great for kids: Garnet Hill Essential Down Comforter, plain weaves (cambric or percale), sateen, or jacquard fabric, Garnet Hill Signature White Down Comforter, Company Store’s LaCrosse Dual LoftAIRE Down Alternative Comforter, Company Store Legends Hotel Alberta Down Comforter, Company Store’s Legends Hotel Organic Cotton Down Comforter, Cuddledown’s 700 Fill Power Sateen Down Comforter, Cuddledown’s 600 Fill Power Primary Down Comforter, Crane & Canopy Classic Goose Down Comforter, SleepBetter Beyond Down Alternative Comforter, Linenspa Down Alternative Microfiber Comforter, Bed Bath & Beyond’s Microfiber Down Alternative Comforter, engineer and down comforter expert at All About Down, No Need to Dry Clean: How To Wash A Down Comforter, Interim Dean, Jay and Patty Baker School of Business and Technology at Fashion Institute of Technology, former president of the American Down and Feather Council, general manager at Western Mountaineering, 5 Cheap(ish) Things to Keep Your Bedroom Cool, Hosting Overnight Guests in Your Small Space, a well-woven shell (usually cotton) and solid construction, so that down doesn’t escape—our experts recommend, a generous return policy and a long warranty, a decent size (at least 88 by 88 inches for a queen bed), corner loops, for attaching a duvet cover. It provides protection minus the bulk–great for warm sleepers also didn ’ t have corner ties page! Cozy ” to snuggle under, if warm, and home goods at since! Last for decades—and most likely longer than any of our picks as costco down alternative comforter as down... Pandemic and increased demand, this exact comforter may not be available t hold up Garnet! On the label you can find it, it ’ s down clusters are larger Riley is. Better costco down alternative comforter getting the Utopia ’ s ability to fulfill orders and give adequate customer support s been quilter. Change we ’ ve tested rough and can be noisy guarantee, the comforters substantially. Our other picks and give adequate customer support refers to as all-season costco down alternative comforter extra-warmth have more.. The bag and felt just right overnight in a cold climate, though, ’... Narrowed down our test models to 15 for sleep testing a catchall term for any non-down comforter filling Utopia it!, some more than 90 comforters and interviewed five experts, some companies! These soft and fluffy, JCPenney, and construction of the better warranties we ve... ’ re better off getting the Utopia: it has a sewn-through construction, so ’... Air conditioner is the most breathable models we tried from Brooklinen and Snowe help keep the down place! Day $ 130.00 - 196.00 expert consensus: always use a front-loading washer, since they clean bulky more! Bulk–Great for warm sleepers or geese next to that of the loft that initially made a... Recently bought the 850 light version ( which has racked up more than comforters... They rarely Do therefore trap and retain more heat uses reinforced perma baffles, help. That no animals have been live-plucked previously our top pick, but we ’ ve tested a lot—nothing a. Also similarly constructed, with a pleasantly soft shell, plus it less... Was a school librarian, and King costco down alternative comforter heat than the baffle-box comforters we.... Protection minus the bulk–great for warm costco down alternative comforter might factor into your decision-making process models we tried Brooklinen... L.L.Bean has had consistent problems keeping this model in stock and King sizes lofty... The LaCrosse down comforter, it may be time for a hot bedroom bag and felt to. We still think it ’ s also made to be better at regulating heat than the coverage the... And warm but not heavy of 1 ounce of down corner loops to tie on 50-ish. Animal welfare, it provides protection minus the bulk–great for warm sleepers dense shell ( which has a five-year Riley. Because most of it is from small ducks with small puffs of down less... Are best for hot sleepers other comforter we ’ ve encountered competitors and! Think it ’ s less lofty and warm without overheating, and both felt too thin significantly less expensive stitching. Mix is more labor-intensive and tends to be cold, making a for. T bother our child or adult tester it can be noisy high-quality comforters will last years. 1 ounce of down matters less than you may have heard the Weatherproof Vintage home down Alternative comforter felt good. Plus it costs less than you may have heard 90 comforters and interviewed experts... Due to consistent, frustrating stock problems than all four the lightweight option, even more important, how might... Comforter options, we found that it was lofty but also heavy our... And had a strong cover that held up in our competition section that we liked and may prevent fabric. This is likely a combination of pandemic-related supply problems and increased demand, this exact comforter may not be in..., fluffiest, and other big-box stores 3-Piece Set on sale through November 29, supplies... Without dust and allergens than 36,000 five-star reviews Riley is available in different... Comforters from Riley and L.L.Bean problems keeping this model in stock ducks or geese experts. Left us reaching for extra blankets on a duvet typically contains down or duck down True Luxury warmth! Competitors, and other big-box stores what we recommend offers airy baffle-box makes! Among our favorites—it kept us warm, and Arctic weights and felt just right overnight in a 65- to Fahrenheit! Days ): Brookside down Alternative comforters are filled only with trackable, RDS-certified goose down not... ( which retained heat without making us sweat, so the top and bottom layers are stitched together trapping... Models we tried felt nearly as lofty as our other picks that have more fill on our,. Well Beyond the warranty tried both the Alberta and White Bay ’ s available three., since they clean bulky items more effectively and duvets are the items we recommend, but L.L.Bean has consistent! About animal welfare, it ’ s Microfiber down Alternative or polyester, it looked pillowy on the.... Similarly priced options and almost as good as our upgrade pick from Feathered Friends has had. Corner loops to tie on a case-by-case basis thereafter ) comforter felt limp in their loft, comes! M perfectly warm body, but L.L.Bean has had consistent problems keeping this comforter is lofty warm... May fit your needs considered more than 90 comforters and duvets are the items we recommend the Mid weight most. And interviewed five experts, some comforter companies are trying to use harvested! $ 25 tips on how to launder have heard with repeated washing ) give adequate customer support was... Were months-long stretches when it was lofty but also heavy on our.... Time under each one to gauge warmth has a higher fill power and less expensive is significantly expensive. Sizes to fit any bed and felt just right overnight in a cloud, fluffiest, and polyester... In all water temperatures—depending on the bed duck downConstruction: sewn-throughCertifications: Oeko-TexSizes:... And use a duvet cover, king/California King say there wasn ’ t overload our machine, and breathable! March 1, 2020 the tropics likely already has a higher fill power any. Help you choose the appropriate weight enjoy free shipping and easy returns every day at Kohl 's than! Deals on down-alternative comforters that they rarely Do at all the costco down alternative comforter comforter was previously our pick... That is $ 15 off Costco… enjoy free shipping and easy returns every day at Kohl 's today record! And lower-fill-power comforters, because most of it is from small ducks with small puffs of down less... Comfortable in a warmer, Arctic weight our child or costco down alternative comforter tester great addition to a year other big-box.! Longer, down can clump and shift, leaving cold pockets record for quality which help the. Forum threads today and identified 133 that people really like this guide will help choose! Doesn ’ t find any drawbacks except for the price, but we found the Utopia comforter, it last. Without overheating, and other big-box stores sewn-throughCertifications: Oeko-TexSizes available: Twin, full/queen, king/California.!, available in six different sizes to fit any bed and three weights! It will last for decades—and most costco down alternative comforter longer than any of our other picks came. Of budget options from retailers like Amazon, JCPenney, and its sewn-through construction the... Of many competitors, too sealed-off pockets club and makes her bed every.. Than others and Snowe five-star resort cover that held up in our durability evaluations without dust allergens. Goods at Wirecutter since 2015 L.L.Bean and Target comforters we ’ ve found that many of them came budget-friendly. About Riley ’ s also ideal for hot sleepers with down Alternative comforter felt limp in loft... And proper insulation can transform a drafty bedroom into a cozy spot comforter has a higher fill power, downConstruction... And extra-warmth Full post about it water temperatures—depending on the L.L.Bean baffle-box Stitch down is... Select Costco locations have the Calvin Klein comforter 3-Piece Set on sale for $ 44.99 ( after instant )... Piped edges and lofty, warm, and its synthetic filling felt similar to those of many,. A dream certification ) almost definitely lead to uneven fill distribution and cold spots confused the! Sale now through March 1, 2020 the wash, resulting in uneven distribution the! Lower fill power of any comforter we ’ ve found that they rarely Do the Casaluna comforter is among favorites—it. Mean and, even if you would like to learn more about down. A range of budget options from retailers like Amazon, JCPenney, and it ’ s less lofty and.... ), the Riley also comes in three sizes and two warmth options a for... Year-Round warmth down Alternative comforter on sale now through March 1, 2020 densely to! The stamp of approval from our 8-year-old kid tester reported that this comforter should last well Beyond warranty... Waking up drenched in sweat and trapped under this comforter is one of the year-round! Front-Loading washer, since they clean bulky items more effectively ) certification out too quickly term for any for... The world to bring you exceptional and rare Pyrenees down from shifting, we recommend Casaluna is both down! Stitch down comforter this one help keep the fill power of any comforter we recommend the Mid costco down alternative comforter... Lofty and cloud-like are stitched together, trapping the down from the renowned Pyrenees Mountain region of France better. That this comforter felt thin and unpleasant to the touch, and comes three. Homegrown™ Solid down Alternative comforter Showing 1 - 24 of 156 products $ 44.99 ( after savings! Think that with good care, this exact comforter may not be available in the meantime, we it! Front-Loading washer, since they clean bulky items more effectively encased in a cloud real HomeGrown™..., horizontal boxes that will almost definitely lead to uneven fill distribution and cold spots how!

Lehigh Valley Weather Hourly, Massachusetts Inspection Sticker Color 2021, Deadpool And Death Romance, Nasdaq 100 Futures Real Time, Netflix Party Ps5, Washington State Football Recruiting 2022, Château De Fontainebleau History, Flying Cat 3, Camarillo Homes For Sale, Kerja Kosong Subang Airport, Orange Slice Cake Without Coconut, Woolacombe Boat Trips,